Navigating Troubled Waters: How to Resolve a Business Dispute

A brass compass on a navy notebook beside a wax-sealed envelope and fountain pen on a wooden desk in warm light

Most business disputes can be resolved without going to court. Keep talking, stay calm, put everything in writing, and check what your contract says, especially its dispute resolution clause. If that doesn't work, the next steps are usually a letter of demand, then mediation, then a tribunal or court as a last resort. Get advice from your business lawyer early: the sooner you do, the more options you have, and the cheaper the fix usually is.

Disagreements are part of life, and part of business. A client who's unhappy and wants their money back. A supplier whose mistake turns into a loss for you. A business partner you no longer see eye to eye with. A team member whose expectations don't match yours.

The good news is that how a dispute ends often comes down to how you prepare, and how you react. I spent 12 years practising as a litigation lawyer, and I've seen how small problems become big ones, and how much time, money and stress can be saved by acting early.

What is a business dispute?

A dispute is any disagreement in a business setting that's causing a problem. Many people think of court straight away, but most disputes never get anywhere near a courtroom. A disagreement with a business partner over how to spend money, a client demanding a refund, or a supplier's error can all be the start of a dispute.

How do I stop a disagreement becoming a dispute?

  1. Get your legals sorted. Clear documents set out what happens before anything goes wrong: your client terms, refund and cancellation policies, payment terms, supplier and contractor agreements, employment agreements, and a partnership or shareholders agreement if you're in business with someone else.

  2. Include a dispute resolution clause. It sets out the steps both sides must follow, such as notice, a meeting and then mediation, before anyone can go to court. It gives you a way to defuse and resolve things quickly and without the high costs.

  3. Put it in writing. After any call or meeting, send a short email confirming the key points and anything agreed. People remember conversations differently, and a written record keeps everyone on the same page.

  4. Communicate, and set expectations early. Many disputes start because something wasn't clarified. Ask questions, and don't be afraid to check you've understood.

What should I do when a dispute arises?

  • Keep the lines of communication open. Don't ignore the person or the problem. If you do, the person will become unhappier and the problem bigger.

  • Get clear on the real issue. Ask questions and listen. What's really going on?

  • Take time to control your emotions. If you react angrily, things escalate quickly. Sleep on it before you reply, and think twice before hitting send on that email. My podcast episode What NOT to do when things go wrong covers this.

  • Check your documents. Find the clause that applies, whether it's cancellation, refunds, payment or termination, and the dispute resolution process you've both agreed to.

  • Write it down. Keep copies of emails, invoices and notes of conversations, with dates.

  • Get advice early. It's never too late to call your business lawyer, but the sooner the better. There are also time limits for bringing some claims, so don't sit on a problem.

How are business disputes resolved?

Most disputes move up a ladder, and most are resolved on the lower rungs:

  1. A direct conversation. Sit down and try to sort it out. Sometimes being the bigger person protects a relationship worth keeping. Record what you agree in writing.

  2. A letter of demand. A formal letter setting out what's owed or what needs to happen, and by when.

  3. Mediation or other dispute resolution. An independent person helps you both reach an agreement. It's faster, less costly and more private than court. The Australian Small Business and Family Enterprise Ombudsman and your state's small business commissioner can help small businesses with low-cost mediation.

  4. A tribunal. Smaller claims, including many consumer and trader disputes, can often go to your state's civil and administrative tribunal, which is quicker and less formal than court.

  5. Court. My advice is to avoid litigation unless it's truly necessary. It's expensive, slow and stressful. That said, some disputes do genuinely need a court to decide them, and if yours does, get the right advice as early as possible.

Be kind to yourself

Working through a dispute takes time and energy, and it will probably cause stress. You don't have to go it alone. When you have an ongoing relationship with your business lawyer, they already know you and your business, so they can get to the heart of the issue quickly and help you find the most efficient path to a resolution.

Ultimately, how your business fares when you hit troubled waters comes down to two things: how well you prepared before you set off, and how you react when problems arise. Get the right legal documents in place, and keep the lines of communication open. If you're facing a dispute, or want to make sure your documents will protect you if one arises, book an introduction call.

This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Your options depend on your specific circumstances.

Frequently asked questions

What is a business dispute?

Any disagreement in a business setting that's causing a problem, such as a client demanding a refund, a supplier's error causing a loss, or a disagreement with a business partner. Most business disputes are resolved without going to court.

What should I do first when a business dispute arises?

Stay calm, keep talking, and put the key points in writing. Check what your contract says, including any dispute resolution clause, and get advice from your business lawyer early.

What is a dispute resolution clause?

A clause in your contract that sets out the steps both parties must follow to resolve a dispute, such as giving notice, meeting and attending mediation, before going to court. It helps you settle disputes quickly and cheaply.

Do I have to go to court to resolve a business dispute?

Usually not. Most disputes are resolved by negotiation, a letter of demand or mediation. Smaller claims can often go to a state tribunal, and court is a last resort.

When should I talk to a lawyer about a dispute?

As early as possible. Early advice gives you more options, can stop a small problem growing, and helps you avoid missing any time limits for making a claim.

Further reading

Tracey Mylecharane

Tracey Mylecharane is the Principal Solicitor and founder of TM Legal Atelier, a boutique commercial law practice working with small and growing service-based businesses, and providing fractional in-house counsel to mid-size businesses Australia-wide. She has more than 20 years' commercial legal experience, was admitted in 2002, lectures at UNSW Law, and hosts the Rise Up in Business podcast.

Previous
Previous

What's Unfair Dismissal? A Guide for Small Business Owners

Next
Next

I've Had a Falling Out With My Business Partner: Now What?